论机器人道德地位的三种研究进路
Should Robots Be Granted Moral Status: A Critical Examination Based on National Security
投稿时间:2025-08-26  修订日期:2025-10-10
DOI:
中文关键词:  机器人  道德地位  国家安全
English Keywords:Robot  moral status  National security
Fund Project:
作者单位邮编
马雷* 南华大学科技进步与安全研究院 421001
徐悦 南华大学马克思主义学院 421001
摘要点击次数: 98
全文下载次数: 0
中文摘要:
      随着自主性机器人在军事和社会领域的应用日益深化,学界对机器人道德地位的判定围绕属性进路和关系进路进行着激烈争议。一方以机器人是否拥有意识、理性等内在属性为判定标准,另一方以机器人和人类在社会互动中形成的关系作为判断标准。但是这两种进路追求统一的、不变的僵化标准,在学理上面临诸多不可克服的困难。本文提出第三种进路,即国家安全进路。这一进路的考察具有目标指向性、情境性、动态性、可调节性。结合马克思主义国家理论和机器人的发展,对国家安全的理解必须实现范式转换。新时代的国家安全,本质上是如何驾驭技术革命、防止社会撕裂并确保国家作为“公共权力”服务于人而非异化于人的终极挑战。因此,机器人道德地位的赋予必须从国家安全出发,根据机器人和社会实践的发展在不同程度上动态调整判定标准。
English Summary:
      :As the application of autonomous robots continues to deepen in military and social domains, academia is engaged in intense debate regarding the determination of robots’ moral status, centering on the attribute approach and the relational approach. One side judges based on whether robots possess intrinsic properties such as consciousness and rationality, while the other side relies on the relationships formed between robots and humans through social interactions. However, both approaches pursue a unified, rigid, and unchanging standard, facing numerous insurmountable theoretical difficulties. This paper proposes a third approach: the national security approach. This approach is characterized by its goal orientation, context dependence, dynamism, and adjustability. In light of Marxist theory of the state and the development of robotics, the understanding of national security must undergo a paradigm shift. In the new era, national security fundamentally represents the ultimate challenge of harnessing technological revolution, preventing social fragmentation, and ensuring that the state, as “public power” serves people rather than becoming alienated from them. Therefore, the assignment of moral status to robots must be based on national security, dynamically addressing the issue of determination standards to varying degrees according to the evolution of robots and social practices.
  查看/发表评论  下载PDF阅读器
关闭